close
close

Trouble making sense of tropical forecasts and models

Trouble making sense of tropical forecasts and models

NEW ORLEANS (WVUE) – Tropical development is possible again this week in the Northwest Caribbean and Gulf of Mexico – the same area formed by Helene.

As of Tuesday morning, October 1, a stormy area near Central America may develop into a tropical depression as atmospheric conditions become more favourable.

Tropical View(WVUE)

The Role of Weather Models

This weather-torn area is confusing the internet as individual model work posts are misconstrued as information from Helene.

This is why it’s important to get your weather information from reliable sources:

Weather computer models are useful to forecasters and have become more accurate over the years. Even so, the atmosphere is a system with many different variables and changes that computer models have difficulty explaining or modeling accurately.

The reason for this is the “butterfly effect”.

Weather is a “chaotic system”; that is, small changes multiply rapidly, leading to more significant effects over time, making long-term predictions difficult.

The further out in time the system is modeled, the greater the potential for error caused by changing variables.

The presence of model error creates a limit on predictability(WVUE)

Models work based on initial conditions (weather data collected by various sensors and satellites). For the most accurate starting conditions you need good data coverage. This is especially difficult in overwater areas where there are fewer weather stations.

Even if there is a good sensor network, there will never be a way to collect data at every moment and at every point.

Therefore, the snapshots of the atmosphere provided to the model on which to base its prediction will never be completely accurate.

The atmosphere is also changing rapidly and constantly, so initial conditions can very quickly become unrepresentative of the current state of the atmosphere.

Models transform these initial conditions, computational power, and complex mathematical equations into an output of predictions.

A single set of variables will be used to achieve this result in a model run.

This is usually what you will encounter when a screenshot of a storm is shown on simulated radar on the internet.

A simulated radar sample from the model is run on October 1 and predicts conditions two weeks later on October 17.(TropicalTidbits.com)

Meteorologists consider these single results a bit conservative, especially in tropical forecasts. Tropical systems are very complex and occur in regions with little data.

This is why hurricane hunters fly between systems to gather information that can be entered and used for more accurate modeling.

There is a lot of uncertainty in model predictions due to the general lack of information, especially before the system is fully formed and satellite data helps.

Ensemble Models and Forecasting Challenges

Ensemble models are more useful in this case. These are running the same model with different variables and parameters to account for uncertainties in the modelling.

Running multiple models or the same model helps build consensus(NOAA)

Analyzing these entire ensembles could help meteorologists reach a consensus on possible future states of the atmosphere modeled by them.

Meteorologists use these communities and their training to formulate the most accurate forecasts possible.

There are situations where there is more uncertainty than usual in a tropical forecast. This often occurs when the upper-level model or area of ​​origin of the tropical system is uncertain.

The area we observed in the Caribbean this week is expected to emerge from the Central American Gyre, an area of ​​low pressure that forms in early autumn and can stimulate tropical systems.

In this case, modeling has difficulty determining the actual point of formation of the storm because the wave does not yet exist or is accompanied by many different low pressure areas interacting with each other.

Until a center forms in the system, models will have difficulty accurately predicting the outcome. Therefore, the path of the storm is not extinguished until a center is formed.

When the National Hurricane Center issues tropical outlooks, the best thing to do is to continue checking the system’s progress until it forms.

You should also always have your hurricane preparedness ready during hurricane season.

It is important to constantly check tropical information because very small changes in the environment can create large changes in the course and intensity of the storm.

That’s why it’s important to get your weather information from reliable sources and ignore online chatter.

Download the Fox 8 News and Weather apps at Fox8Live.com/apps or from the App Store and Google Play.(WVUE)

See a spelling or grammatical error in our story? Click here to report this. Please include the title.

Subscribe to Fox 8 YouTube channel.